Events
Most Iconic Super Bowl Plays That Still Amaze Fans
The 20 most iconic Super Bowl plays of all time, ranked by impact, difficulty, and timing. The catches and stops that actually decided titles.
Think the Super Bowl’s most famous plays are obvious?
Not quite.
This list ranks the 20 most iconic moments by championship impact, difficulty, timing, and how long they haunted highlight reels.
You’ll get the clutch catches, impossible grabs, gut stops and jaw-dropping trickery that actually changed titles, not just flashy clips.
Read on to relive the plays that still make fans hold their breath and see why each earned its place in football lore.
Ranked List of 20 Legendary Super Bowl Plays

Ranking the most iconic Super Bowl plays ever means weighing four things at once. Championship impact. How hard the play actually was to pull off. The moment it happened in. And how long it’s stuck around in the sport’s memory. A great catch in a blowout just doesn’t carry the same weight as a desperate heave that saves a season. Some of these plays won rings outright. Others became part of NFL history simply because nobody who saw them live has forgotten them.
Here’s the order, built from decades of broadcast highlights, locker room retellings, and championship game tape.
| Rank | Play | Super Bowl and Date | Teams | Situation and Participants | Result and Significance | Video Link or Placeholder |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | David Tyree’s Helmet Catch | Super Bowl XLII, February 3, 2008 | New York Giants vs. New England Patriots | Fourth quarter, 1:15 left, third and 5. Eli Manning slipped away from a near sack, scrambled right, and launched a desperate throw downfield to David Tyree. | Tyree pinned the ball against his own helmet while falling backward, somehow holding on through contact from Rodney Harrison. The catch kept New York’s drive alive and set up the go ahead touchdown that ended New England’s undefeated run. |
|
| 2 | Malcolm Butler’s goal line interception | Super Bowl XLIX, February 1, 2015 | New England Patriots vs. Seattle Seahawks | Second and goal from the 1, 20 seconds left. Seattle lined up to throw a slant instead of handing it to Marshawn Lynch, with Russell Wilson targeting Ricardo Lockette. | Butler, an undrafted rookie, jumped the route before the ball even got there and picked it off at the goal line. That interception sealed the title for New England and instantly turned into one of the most debated play calls in championship history. |
|
| 3 | Santonio Holmes’ toe tap touchdown | Super Bowl XLIII, February 1, 2009 | Pittsburgh Steelers vs. Arizona Cardinals | Fourth quarter, 35 seconds left, Steelers trailing. Ben Roethlisberger threw to the back corner of the end zone, where Holmes had to twist his body in the air to get to it. | Holmes caught it at full extension and dragged both toes in bounds before tumbling out. The score gave Pittsburgh its sixth championship and capped one of the best final drives the Super Bowl has ever seen. | (((alt-img3))) |
| 4 | James Harrison’s 100 yard interception return | Super Bowl XLIII, February 1, 2009 | Pittsburgh Steelers vs. Arizona Cardinals | Final play of the first half, Arizona at the goal line. Kurt Warner looked for a quick touchdown pass, but Harrison read it from his linebacker spot before the ball even left Warner’s hand. | Harrison picked it off and sprinted the entire length of the field as time expired, diving into the end zone right as the half ended. It’s still the longest play in Super Bowl history, and it flipped the game’s momentum completely. | (((alt-img4))) |
| 5 | The Philly Special | Super Bowl LII, February 4, 2018 | Philadelphia Eagles vs. New England Patriots | Fourth and goal from the 1, late in the first half. Philadelphia ran a trick play, direct snap to running back Corey Clement, pitch to tight end Trey Burton, then a pass back to quarterback Nick Foles. | Foles caught it in the end zone for the score. A backup quarterback catching a touchdown pass in the biggest moment of the season? That call became a symbol of coaching nerve, and it helped Philadelphia win its first Super Bowl title. | (((alt-img5))) |
| 6 | Mike Jones stops Kevin Dyson | Super Bowl XXXIV, January 30, 2000 | St. Louis Rams vs. Tennessee Titans | Final play of the game, Titans at the 10 yard line, down by 7. Dyson caught a short pass and stretched for the goal line. | Jones wrapped up Dyson’s legs a single yard short as time ran out, preserving the Rams’ championship. Fans just call it “The Tackle” now. It’s one of the great goal line stops in NFL history. | (((alt-img6))) |
| 7 | Julian Edelman’s diving catch | Super Bowl LI, February 5, 2017 | New England Patriots vs. Atlanta Falcons | Fourth quarter, under five minutes left, Patriots trailing badly and needing a spark to keep their comeback hopes alive. |



